The English Premier League has recorded a joint-record six refereeing errors in a single weekend following a review by its Key Match Incidents (KMI) Panel. The mistakes, which occurred during the latest round of fixtures, have sparked fresh debate about officiating standards and the effectiveness of Video Assistant Referee (VAR) technology.
According to the panel’s assessment, six on-field decisions were incorrect, matching the highest number of errors recorded in one weekend since the early part of the 2023/24 season.
Among the most controversial incidents was the decision not to award Arsenal a penalty after Kai Havertz was pulled down inside the penalty area by Hull City’s Nobel Mendy. Despite a VAR review, referee Farai Hallam maintained his original decision because Havertz was considered to be in an offside position. The panel unanimously ruled that the penalty should have been awarded.
Another major controversy involved Everton defender James Tarkowski, who was found to have pulled Coventry City’s Caleb Yirenkyi by his hair inside the penalty area. The panel voted unanimously that Coventry should have received a penalty and that VAR should have intervened.
Other incorrect decisions included a handball incident involving Everton’s Thierno Barry, a controversial late penalty awarded to Crystal Palace against Liverpool, an incorrectly awarded penalty to Ipswich against Bournemouth and a missed second-yellow-card offence involving Bournemouth’s Marcus Tavernier.
Interestingly, the panel concluded that only two of the six errors should have been corrected through VAR intervention. The remaining four were considered incorrect on-field decisions but did not meet the threshold for VAR interference.
The findings have renewed questions about the consistency of refereeing decisions, particularly as supporters continue to express frustration over controversial calls.
The KMI Panel reviews major incidents after every round of Premier League matches, with its assessments also contributing to referees’ performance evaluations and bonus payments




