The federal sex trafficking trial against the Alexander brothers is hurtling toward a verdict, and now a reality TV star has stepped forward with her own explosive accusations. Tracy Tutor, known for her six-season run on Bravo’s Million Dollar Listing Los Angeles, filed a civil lawsuit Thursday against Oren Alexander, accusing him of drugging and sexually assaulting her in 2014. The complaint, filed in New York federal court, arrives just as jury deliberations are expected to begin in the brothers’ criminal trial.
Tutor, a Beverly Hills real estate broker who now works for Compass, alleges Alexander used his position at Douglas Elliman to lure her to New York under the guise of a professional dinner before the assault occurred.
According to the complaint, Tutor was invited to fly from Los Angeles to New York City in February 2014 for a dinner with top brokers at Douglas Elliman, where Alexander worked at the time. The event was part of the company’s “Top Producer Cocktail Reception” hosted by then-CEO Howard Lorber.
During the dinner, Tutor was handed a drink, a large pink cocktail she later noted she would not have ordered for herself, preferring tequila sodas at the time. Shortly after consuming the drink, she blacked out and lost memory of the rest of the evening.
A male friend accompanying Tutor grew concerned when he couldn’t locate her at the table. Searching the venue, he found her in a men’s bathroom stall with Oren Alexander, whose shirt was unbuttoned as he kissed her and touched her intimately. The friend described Tutor as acting “out of her mind”, completely out of character.
When the friend confronted Alexander, an argument ensued. The friend eventually left, asking someone else to ensure Tutor returned safely to her hotel.
Tutor now recalls waking up the next morning in someone else’s hotel room. She noticed her tampon had been removed and that she was surrounded by blood. Her purse was missing, later discovered to be in the possession of Alexander’s assistant, who returned it to her.
She first shared her story publicly with The New York Times in July 2024, marking the first time she had spoken about the episode.
Oren Alexander, 38, and his brothers Tal, 39, and Alon, 38, are currently on trial in the Southern District of New York on federal sex trafficking charges. Jury deliberations are expected to begin this week after a month-long trial featuring testimony from 11 women who described being drugged, raped, or sexually trafficked by one or more of the brothers.
Federal prosecutors allege the brothers ran a decades-long sex trafficking conspiracy, using their wealth and power to entice women before assaulting them. In a January filing, prosecutors revealed that more than 40 women have accused at least one of the brothers of rape or sexual assault spanning nearly 20 years.
During closing arguments, Assistant U.S. Attorney Andrew Jones described the brothers’ alleged tactics as a consistent “playbook”: luring women, drugging them, and assaulting them . One woman testified she wrote “RAPIST” on a bedroom door with eyeliner after witnessing an assault at a Hamptons mansion.
Prosecutors also presented a video of Oren Alexander appearing to rape a drugged 17-year-old in 2009, which he allegedly recorded on his laptop. The brothers have pleaded not guilty to all charges and denied any wrongdoing.
Jason Goldman, Oren Alexander’s attorney, issued a forceful denial of Tutor’s allegations. “Ms. Tutor and her counsel have timed the filing of this salacious and demonstrably false lawsuit for maximum media impact, choosing the eve of jury deliberations in the federal trial despite the fact that the allegations are more than a decade old and have already been aired publicly,” Goldman said in a statement.
Goldman characterized the lawsuit as “nothing more than a transparent attempt to create headlines and taint the proceedings at a critical moment”. He expressed confidence the jury would focus on evidence presented in court rather than “opportunistic litigation tactics”.
Tutor’s lawsuit cites New York’s Victims of Gender-Motivated Violence Protection Act and the federal Trafficking Victims Protection and Reauthorization Act. The complaint notes that Alexander “had a practice of drugging and sexually assaulting women, as several women have now alleged,” and that he “used his position and stature as a star agent at Douglas Elliman to lure women”.
A verdict in the criminal trial against the Alexander brothers could come as early as Friday. The outcome will not directly affect Tutor’s civil case, which will proceed separately. The brothers also face more than two dozen additional civil lawsuits from women who have accused them of sexual assault .
For Tutor, the lawsuit represents a formal pursuit of accountability nearly 12 years after the alleged assault. “Oren had a practice of drugging and sexually assaulting women,” her complaint states simply.
